Wild West Rarities Glitter in November

November auctions were rich with numismatic rarities from the Old West mint in Carson City. Over $20,000,000 went under the hammer, setting one world record and exceeding expectations on numerous occasions.

Bidding is always enthusiastic for Carson City minted coins, from Seated Liberty Dimes to Morgan Silver Dollars, to old west gold. But November bidding was especially fierce for major rarities baring the desirable double “CC” mint mark. On the night of November 11, an 1870-CC $20 Liberty sold for a world record $1,620,000. This exact same specimen sold just seven years ago for $411,250 which confirms how desirable the coins of Carson City truly are to high-end collector and investors.

The 1.6 million 1870-CC rarity was not the only CC minted treasure drawing attention. During the auction, two other Carson City gold pieces from the same collection also sold for substantially more than expected.

One of them, an 1872-CC double eagle $20, realized $144,000. Unlike the 1870-CC $20 Liberty, the 1872-CC is not a legendary rarity. Its high price can be attributed to the fact that it’s graded NGC MS61, and there exist but two coins certified finer.

An 1877-CC double eagle, graded MS62, likewise sold for $144,000, and is highly regarded as a scarce Carson City date; this coin, too, is tied for the finest certified, making it a valuable cornerstone to a collection.

But all that glittered from the foray of Carson City coinage was not necessarily gold.

Date

Description

Service

Grade

Price Realized

1873-CC

Seated Arrows Dime

NGC

MS65

$180,000

1875-CC

Twenty Cent

PCGS

MS66

$84,000

1870-CC

Seated Quarter

NGC

XF40

$26,400

1875-CC

Seated Quarter

PCGS

MS65

$24,000

1876-CC

Seated Quarter

NGC

MS67

$16,800

1873-CC

Seated Half

PCGS

MS63

$12,600

1874-CC

Seated Half

PCGS

AU58

$16,200

1876-CC

Seated Half

PCGS

MS66

$21,600

1877-CC

Seated Half

NGC

MS67

$18,000

1878-CC

Seated Half

PCGS

MS63

$17,400

1870-CC

Seated Dollar

PCGS

MS62

$24,000

1873-CC

Seated Dollar

NGC

MS61

$114,000

1874-CC

Trade Dollar

PCGS

MS65

$16,800

1878-CC

Trade Dollar

PCGS

MS62

$16,800

1878-CC

$5 Liberty

PCGS

AU58

$72,000

1872-CC

$10 Liberty

PCGS

AU50

$25,200

1873-CC

$10 Liberty

NGC

AU55

$57,600

1875-CC

$10 Liberty

NGC

MS60

$75,000

1878-CC

$10 Liberty

NGC

AU55

$40,800

1884-CC

$10 Liberty

NGC

MS62

$43,200

1893-CC

$10 Liberty

PCGS

MS61PL               

$30,000

1870-CC

$20 Liberty

PCGS

AU53

$1,620,000

1872-CC

$20 Liberty

NGC

MS61

$144,000

1877-CC

$20 Liberty

PCGS

MS62

$144,000

“Enthusiasm for Carson City coinage remains high, especially for scarce dates or top-grade examples”, says Brian Hodge, senior buyer for Finest Known. “CC gold led the charge, with mind blowing bidding for the 1870-CC double eagle. The strong prices realized this past month confirms the strength in these Wild West rarities.”